| 10: | One of my all-time favorites |
| 9: | Great game |
| 8: | Very good, I'll almost always agree to play |
| 7: | Good game; I'll usually agree to play |
| 6: | Good game, will play from time to time |
| 5: | Decent game, above average, don't play it much |
| 4: | Below average, either fun but flawed or not so much fun, or just one that doesn't excite me. |
| 3: | Poor game; I won't play it unless the rules are changed |
| 2: | Bad game; either broken badly or I strongly dislike it |
| 1: | Total loser for some reason: hopeless rules, or it's a bad version of a different, much better game, or it's just completely silly without adequate chrome to make it fun anyway. |
The most important break is between 5 and 6. 6s and up I play and 5s and down I don't. In general.
| 10s: | 8 |
| 9s: | 14 |
| 8s: | 17 |
| 7s: | 40 |
| 6s: | 37 |
| 5s: | 24 |
| 4s: | 29 |
| 3s: | 20 |
| 2s: | 17 |
| 1s: | 7 |
Barbu 10 Bridge 10 Durch die Wuste 10 1856 10 Poker 10 Tales of the Arabian Nights 10 Up Front 10 Wizards (AH) 10 Auf Heller und Pfennig 9 Bohnanza 9 Carabande 9 Die Macher 9 1830 9 Euphrat & Tigris 9 History of the World 9 Kingmaker 9 Nuclear Armageddon 9 6 Nimmt! 9 Samurai (Knizia) 9 Take It Easy 9 2038 9 Wildlife Adventure 9 Backgammon 8 Can't Stop 8 Castle of Magic 8 Creights 8 Empires of the Middle Ages 8 Gin 8 Groo 8 Iron Horse 8 Linie 1 8 Merchant of Venus 8 Modern Art 8 Outpost 8 Roadkill 8 Stellar Conquest 8 Target 8 Viva Pamplona! 8 X-Pasch 8 Abbot's Ultima 7 Airlines 7 Ancient Conquest 7 Awful Green Things 7 Blackbeard 7 Bridgette 7 Cafe International 7 Campaign Trail 96 7 Chill: Black Morn Manor 7 City of Sorcerers 7 Coup d'Etat 7 Deluxe Illuminati 7 Die Siedler von Catan 7 DinoHunt 7 Diplomacy 7 1835 7 Elfenland 7 Entdecker 7 Facts in Five 7 Fast Food Franchise 7 Filthy Rich 7 Freibeuter 7 Golem 7 Guillotine 7 Hearts 7 King Arthur's Knights 7 Lonely Mountain 7 Machievelli 7 Manhattan 7 Mississippi Queen 7 Modern Naval Battles 7 Mr. President 7 Nuclear War 7 Oh Hell 7 Rail Baron 7 Riddle of the Ring 7 Samarkand 7 Spekulation 7 Stock Car Card Game (McGartlin) 7 Survive! 7 Ace of Aces 6 Acquire 6 Army of Darkness 6 Careers 6 Chainsaw Warrior 6 Circus Maximus 6 Cosmic Wimpout 6 Cribbage 6 Dampfross 6 Detroit/Cleveland Grand Prix 6 Formula De 6 Freight Train 6 Give me the Brain 6 Guerilla 6 Grass 6 Halunken und Spelunken 6 Hare and Tortoise 6 Kahuna 6 Kill Dr. Lucky 6 Liars Dice 6 Lord of the Fries 6 Magic: the Gathering 6 Mine! 6 Nanuuk! 6 Netrunner 6 Ogre 6 Pictionary 6 Risk 6 Robo Rally 6 Silverton 6 Sinbad (FT) 6 Sorcerer's Cave 6 Source of the Nile 6 Subway Vigilante 6 Um Reifenbreite 6 Wucherer 6 Xxxenophile 6 Caesar & Cleopatra 5 Civilization 5 Chess 5 City of Chaos 5 Clue 5 1853 5 El Grande 5 Escape from Colditz 5 Expedition 5 Kaliko 5 Katzenjammer Blues 5 Monopoly 5 Mare Mediterraneum 5 Middle Earth: the Wizards 5 Mille Bornes 5 Once Upon a Time 5 Republic of Rome 5 Richtofens War 5 Scrabble 5 Schnappchen Jagd 5 Stratego 5 Uno 5 Wizard of Firetop Mountain 5 Wizwar 5 Yahtzee 5 Auf Achse 4 Basari 4 Cosmic Encounter 4 Elfenwizards 4 Empire Builder 4 Excalibur (Wotan) 4 Family Business 4 For Sale 4 Fossil 4 Gateway to the Stars 4 Get the Goods 4 Iron Dragon 4 Legends of Robin Hood (AH) 4 Game of Life 4 Lowenherz 4 Medici 4 Metropolis 4 Musketiere 4 Napoleon (Columbia) 4 Naval War 4 Palmyra 4 Princess Ryans Star Marines 4 Safe Return Doubtful 4 Scotland Yard 4 Spies! 4 Throneworld 4 Time Agent 4 Tonga Bonga 4 The Willow Game 4 Adel Verpflichtet 3 Cheops 3 Die Siedler Kartenspiel 3 Down with the King 3 Dune 3 Dungeonquest 3 Elric 3 Enemy in Sight 3 Exxtra 3 Eurorails 3 The Great Dalmuti 3 Myth Fortunes 3 Road to the White House 3 Serenissima 3 Sixteen Thirty Something 3 Suzerain 3 Sternenhimmel 3 Venice Connection 3 Xanth 3 Zoff im Buffalo 3 Assassin 2 Banana Republic 2 Corporate Shuffle 2 Die Hanse 2 Executive Decision 2 Falling 2 Giant (JMG) 2 King Arthur (Wotan) 2 Mu 2 Mystic War 2 Pico 2 2 Quest for Power 2 Safari Jack 2 Supremacy 2 Titan 2 Wadjet 2 Wizard 2 Before I Kill You, Mr. Bond 1 Bleeding Sherwood 1 Darkover 1 Fluxx 1 Pirateer 1 Temple of the Beastman 1 Trumpet 1